Every once in a while a bill comes along that reveals a group’s true colors. Rep. Rodney Schad’s bill to allow for travel hardship transfers is just such a bill. It would allow transfer to a different school district if the student lives more than 17 miles from their school and there’s another school much closer.
Over the past four years, only 33 students have requested transfer from a special committee set up under current statutes. But the requests are rarely granted. In committee, we heard testimony from parents who spoke of their children wetting their pants because the school bus ride was so long – and of course getting bullied as a result. We heard other testimony about how, where the student was involved in extra-curricular activities, they consistently leave home before the sun comes up and get back home after it goes down. We heard other testimony about the negative impact that hour-long bus rides each way have on academic performance.
And yet, despite the bill affecting just a tiny number of Missouri school children, school administrators oppose the bill. One family supporting the change explained what it’s about very well in the P-D:
Kraft has two daughters whose tuition in Rockwood schools is provided by the Washington district. He successfully argued to the state education department that the 18.8 miles and lengthy bus ride from his home to the Washington schools made them worthy of a hardship transfer. But, concerned that his home district and others would continue to fight such arrangements, he hired a lobbyist to push the bill.
“If you’ve got some families around the state who have a huge commute back and forth and it’s a real hardship … and they’re lucky enough to have a school that’s a lot closer and in the right direction and that school has room for them, why in the world wouldn’t we try to make that happen?” said Kraft, who also has two elementary school-age children enrolled in private schools.
“I’ve listened to hours of arguments by superintendents who are against this. I don’t remember hearing one time where they ever brought up the kids. … Its all about, ‘What if the kids leave? What if we lose too many students?’ It’s all about money.”
Unlike Kraft, Massman’s pleas to the state for a transfer have thus far failed. But like Kraft, Massman has asked legislators to change the law and recently testified in favor of the bill.
“It’s an issue of the students going to the closer schools so they don’t have to have their brain rattled on the bus and then come home all tired to do homework,” Massman said. “And then they can attend extracurricular activities with their friends because they’re close enough. … The bottom line is the kids.“
It’s disappointing to me that a bill like this can’t get across the finish line – and it goes to show the extremism of the people who oppose any change whatsoever to education.